in

Carrie Episode 1 Review: “First Period” — A Chilling New Start

Carrie (Summer H. Howell) looks down, bewildered.
Summer H. Howell plays Carrie in Carrie. Image Courtesy of Amazon Prime TV.

The following review contains spoilers for Carrie Episode 1 (S1E1), “First Period” (written and directed by Mike Flanagan)


Mike Flanagan’s retelling of Stephen King’s novel, Carrie, differentiates itself immediately from previous adaptations by showing us the aftermath of Carrie’s (Summer H. Howell) revenge firsthand, right from the start of the episode. “911. What’s your emergency?” an operator answers, while footage of the burning school and audio from several callers plays over haunting imagery. Not only is Ewen High School ablaze, but Main St. has caught fire as well. In fact, the whole town has been decimated.

Unspeakable horrors have occurred, and Carrie was the instigator.  We know this from interviews with Carrie’s classmates, friends, and enemies. Opinions of Carrie range from “kind” to “bully” to “monster” to “victim.” The main interviewee, a young girl named Sue (Siena Agudong), calls Carrie a friend. As the interviewer asks her questions, Sue insists there’s one thing no one will understand, even after 200 deaths. “We were kids,” she claims, “just trying to do our best.”

These opening moments serve as a framing device for an excellent first episode that skillfully balances character development, chilling moments, and some horrific imagery. From this installment alone, it’s clear that Flanagan has a superb handle on the subject matter.

Summer H. Howell is an excellent pick for Carrie. She has an innocent face that belies a more inquisitive and intelligent side. It’s easy to read her emotions, as Carrie comes into school fully trusting, yet not as naive as those around her might think. There is no trace of a sinister side to her, but she is portrayed as quite resilient. As she navigates her school days, she falls into a friend group consisting of Sue and her best friend, Chris Hargensen (Alison Thornton). As Carrie begins to rely on Sue, viewers can feel Chris’s agitation and jealousy. Both Agudong and Thornton manage to sell their bond, and it’s easy to tell, as it should be, that Chris is the more cold-hearted of the two.

Sue (Siena Agudong) smiles at Carrie off camera (Summer H. Howell)
Siena Agudong plays Sue in Carrie. Image courtesy of Amazon MGM Studios.

Part of the reason for Chris’s cold nature is most definitely due to the abrasive nature of her father, John (Michael Trucco). He swears at Chris, selfishly not providing the time she needs to talk to him. In fact, he talks down to her. His character is a perfect counterpart for Carrie’s mother, Margaret (Samantha Sloyan).

Having lost a husband to a freak accident at the beginning of the episode, Margaret has spent her time with Carrie isolated from the outside world in a kind of Christian Fanatic bubble. Deeply distrusting of the government, the school system, and most of the outside world, she’s trained Carrie to be solely reliant on her. There’s no doubt that Margaret is a monster, yet Sloyan’s portrayal also shows that deep inside, she harbors a horrible, twisted love for her daughter. It’s easy to assume that Carrie’s father, Ralph (Tahmoh Penikett), corrupted her.

Sloyan gives an excellent performance in a scene alongside Matthew Lillard as Principal Grayle, when she accuses him of purposefully using shooting drills to traumatize Carrie. Grayle stands there, bewildered, unsure of how to react. Margaret is determined to protect her daughter from the outside world, at any cost. Even if she herself is dealing the most damage to Carrie and compounding her untold trauma.

That trauma is something that Carrie specifically has to deal with, especially at school when the shooting drill is underway. Aside from rocks cascading down on Carrie’s house when she was a child, this is the only sign of her telekinetic/pyrokinetic powers so far in this episode, as she causes an entire TV stand to fall off the side of the wall. She lunges back into Sue for safety, but Sue responds harshly. This serves as a turning point for Sue, who tells her boyfriend, Tommy (Joel Oulette), that she should’ve been softer on her.

Carrie (Summer H. Howell) is on her knees in the school shower, crying, with feminine hygiene products scattered around her.
Summer H. Howell plays Carrie in Carrie. Image courtesy of Amazon MGM Studios.

Unfortunately, when that scene shows up, Sue does not lend a hand. As Carrie is met with bewilderment and confusion at the blood spilling onto her white pants, and as the other teens pummel Carrie with maxi pads and tampons, Sue just stands in line with the other girls. Although she’s not screaming “Plug it up!” her silence still speaks volumes. Carrie is sprawled on the floor in tears, certain she’s dying. She desperately needs help, but in her cowardice, Sue does not give it.

Carrie’s response to the harassment causes a light to short circuit, and somewhere out there someone is listening. An unknown character reacts to the outburst like a “starburst.” Her ears bleed, but then the blood disappears. She talks to her superior, informing her of Carrie’s power. “Where?” the woman asks.

In the closing moments of the episode, we return to Sue’s interview. She foreshadows Chris and Billy’s (Arthur Conti) sabotage of Carrie’s special moment and how Tommy dies. Everyone asks about that, as well as Carrie. But they’re not asking the right questions, she declares, there were people there that night she didn’t even know. Because as much as people want to focus on Carrie. It wasn’t just her that shares the blame.

Taking a look at the previews for the upcoming season, we can get a sense of the meaning behind Sue’s words. Apparently, a social media scourge descends upon Ewen High and the town, and no one is left untouched. The onslaught stems from Carrie’s unfortunate period incident. This sets up a perfect way for the show to comment on the dangers of social media.

I expect also from the sneak peek that Carrie will fall in more with Sue and Chris, until things go hugely haywire, resulting in a fallout with Chris. Chris and Billy seem to get up to trouble of their own, dropping bricks over bridges onto unsuspecting cars below. Finally, it seems as if Margaret will be pushing Carrie into some violence of her own.

Overall, I’m very impressed with what Flanagan has done with this first episode of his adaptation of Carrie. He’s taken something classic and updated it with current themes, while still retaining the core storyline. The amount of dread he was able to instill with the “period” scene was tremendous. If he can make us feel for Carrie during these moments, I wonder in what ways he’ll grab our hearts when she turns towards the darkness dormant within her.

Written by Aaron Ploof

One Comment

Leave a Reply
  1. I never made it through the first episode, watched the recap at the end and bits and pieces of the final episode. They never should have named this “Carrie”. Easily the worst adaptation of a King book since The Dark Tower. What a waste of everyone’s time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *