The following recap contains spoilers for Crystal Lake S1E1 “Camp Crystal” (story written by Bryan Fuller and Brad Caleb Kane and directed by Michael Lennox). Spoilers also include plot points from the Friday the 13th collection of movies.
Almost 23 years to the day after the events of Friday, June 13th, 1979, a character from perhaps the most impactful television show of all time delivered its most iconic line:
“You come at the king, you best not miss.”
Omar mutters that line on The Wire, and it has now become culturally synonymous with understanding that if you are going to step up and challenge the best at something, you must absolutely rise to the challenge. Almost 23 years to the day after that quote was uttered, Brad Caleb Kane and his team began a mission to pick up the mantle of two icons of the horror movie genre: Pamela and Jason Voorhees.
Now, we can argue whether Jason/Pamela Voorhees are the kings of the horror or slasher genre, but one thing is undeniable. Jason is on the Mount Rushmore of horror movie killers. Jason gets a spot with Michael Myers, Freddy Krueger, and probably Leatherface from The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, although I am taking nominations for that spot before we begin the work.
What Kane and his team of writers, directors, and actors set out to do was to tell a story that fills in the gaps of perhaps the greatest slasher duo of all time, Pamela Voorhees and her son Jason. After a long, bitter battle to get this show made, and a full 17 years after the last Friday the 13th property was delivered on screen, the eight-episode Crystal Lake on Peacock launches today, and we get to decide whether they hit or missed when they came at one of the horror kings.
Before diving into the premiere episode, “Camp Crystal,” it’s important to level-set the franchise and what this show is trying to do. After watching all eight episodes, it’s my strong feeling that this show is trying to supplement the existing material and expand on the lore and mystery surrounding the Voorhees family. In some ways, this series does this expertly. In other ways, it’s confounding and borderline unnecessary.
This series is very much a prequel to the majority of events from the original Friday the 13th, but one might also describe it as a reimagining of the circumstances, the history, and the trauma that transformed Pamela and Jason Voorhees into the murderers we see in the films. The movies leave a lot of holes unfilled and stories untold, and Crystal Lake seeks to plug those up with a history that describes what it takes to create a couple of monsters.
What we think we know about Pamela Voorhees (Linda Cardellini) is immediately tested from the opening shot of the series, when we see Pam covered in blood from head to toe, standing above a sink, pulling someone else’s tooth out of her hand.

Coming into this show, Friday the 13th gives us nine murders, and we are immediately meant to wonder which one provides this graphic and gory moment. But as we will soon learn, Pam’s body count is higher than the movie would lead us to believe. But that’s a story that needs to start at the beginning, which is exactly where the episode takes us.
1971 — Nine Months Earlier
In mid-summer 1971,* Pam and Jason live in a comfortable, quaint little home in Crystal Lake, New Jersey. While Pam winds down for the night with an episode of The Don Knotts Show, two important things are introduced. First is a commercial for Bellflower Chemical, which is lingered on too long for us not to notice and pretend that it won’t matter later. The second is her 11-year-old son, Jason (Callum Vinson).
(*The first major deviation from the movie canon comes with the change in years. In Friday the 13th, Jason’s death happens in 1957, Pam kills the counselors responsible in 1958, and then is basically dormant—as far as we know—until the counselors arrive in June 1979. Crystal Lake decides to make Jason’s birth year 1960, and he is 11 years old when we pick up with the story in 1971. Since the creators have stated that the dates of Friday the 13th are canon and won’t be altered, this means Jason is 19 at the time of the first movie, instead of in his 30s when his original birthdate was 1946. The reasons why they make this change will become clear by the end of the season.)
Keeping with the descriptions about Jason from the movies, he has a number of physical deformities, including an oversized head and warped facial features. But other than that, he seems to be a normal kid who can’t go to sleep because he is worried about having to go back to camp the next day. Pam is a cook at Camp Crystal Lake and brings Jason with her so she (or the counselors) can keep an eye on him.

I was surprised that Jason’s drowning came so early in the season. This event, brought on by Jason being bullied, his trying to keep his friend Grace (Gwendolyn Sundstrom) out of trouble, and counselors Barry (Phoenix Parnevik) and Claudette (Danielle Kotch) sneaking off to have sex in the boathouse, happens in the first half of the series premiere. By the time the drowning happens, it becomes clear this series will focus on what happens in the nine or so months after this moment that contributes to Pam devolving into a mass murderer.
Months Later
Some weeks later, we are introduced to the local folks of Crystal Lake. Ralph (Nick Cordileone), a staple of the first two films as the town lunatic, is out setting traps in the woods. Rita (Joy Suprano) and Enos (Daniel Stewart Sherman) enjoy some morning coffee and some of Rita’s erotic literature at the diner. And we meet Police Chief Levon “Lee” Brooks (William Catlett) and his deputy, Officer “Dorf” Dorfman (Cameron Scoggins), for the first time. Dorf and Lee find Pam on the dock looking out over the lake where Jason drowned, where she apparently spends time every single day. She’s wearing the iconic blue sweater we see in the first film.
(*Enos is the truck driver who unknowingly drives Annie to her death at the beginning of Friday the 13th before the other counselors arrive.)
We flash back to sometime in the year before Jason’s drowning, when Pam and Jason get a package full of hunting supplies. Jason is ecstatic to find a tent, a nature guide, some fire starter material, and is curious about the “tool” that comes in the package, which turns out to be quite a large machete. Jason holds it over his head, declaring, “The woods are mine!” in the least subtle imagery-based foreshadowing that has ever been on a television screen.

During the unboxing, we see Jason suffer from a stroke, where he becomes incapacitated and starts foaming at the mouth. Pam has to give him pills and stay with him until it subsides. And it’s clear Jason is suffering from more than just physical deformities. There are internal medical problems as well, and Jason needs his mother to help him through those.
Late Spring 1972
According to town conversations, Jason has been missing for about nine months, and a body has never been discovered. Pam tells Lee that she is trying to move on, but just doesn’t know how to do it. Lee recommends that she come to the annual Crystal Lake Founders’ Day celebration. Pam reluctantly agrees and even begins to banter with Lee, commenting on his new shoes. “$11.95! Best shoes a cop’s salary can buy,” he says.
It soon becomes clear that attending this event down by Crystal Lake was a terrible idea. Kids start shooting off fireworks, kids are swimming in the lake, Claudette and Barry approach her about wanting to do a memorial for Jason, and Pam learns for the first time that the owner of Camp Crystal Lake plans to reopen for the first time that summer.
This sends Pam into a traumatic tailspin, and she begins shouting at the kids in the lake, including young Grace, that they are all going to drown and they have to get out of the water. Lee gets her out of there quickly and drives her home so she can calm down and sleep it off.

When she arrives home, she finds two men waiting for her in her driveway. Ed Shubani (Aaron Serotsky) and Benny Muntrick (Don DiPetta) say they are from the New Jersey State Police and have an update on Jason that they want to tell her inside the house. Jason’s body was apparently found about five miles away, and they need Pam to come with them so she can identify it.
I liked the detail that people suffering from trauma will begin to focus on little things they can control, so Pam remarks that Benny’s shoes are tracking dirt all over her house. When he cleans off his shoes, she sees how expensive they look, and we are reminded of Lee’s comments about his $11.95 shoes. Pam excuses herself to the bathroom to have some time to think, but Ed and Benny soon begin to try to actively and violently tranquilize her and drag her out of the house.
Pam grabs a pair of scissors and stabs Benny before slashing his throat, and he dies, bleeding out in her bathtub. Ed witnesses what happens and drags her out to the living room, throwing her into a closet. It wouldn’t be a Friday the 13th vehicle without a machete death, and Pam grabs hers from the closet and splits Ed’s head open, but not before slicing off a little appetizer of skin from his face on her first blow.
With Ed seemingly dead, Pam goes through his wallet and finds a business card for SunBun Solutions and a newspaper article that talks about Jason’s drowning (with the name “Argonaut” written next to it), and the mother’s reaction, with the name “Wittering” written there. We flash (in a very Stranger Things vibe) to a sterile hallway that has a door with the Bellflower logo and the word Argonaut on it. Pam and Jason have a connection to this place, but what it is and why it matters will have to wait for another time.

For now, Pam has two dead bodies in her living room and the Police Chief trying to check on her to make sure she is ok. Late at night, Pam packs up the bodies, gets them into her trunk, takes them to the woods, covers them in tuna and honey, and drags them into a bear den deep in the forest. As she looks at what she has done, she has a vision of young Jason standing with her.
Even after just one episode, we can begin to see the foundation upon which the architecture of Pamela’s downward spiral will be built. She is suffering from the trauma of losing her son. There are apparently evil, powerful men involved with some kind of company out to get her. And we know she will soon learn about Claudette and Barry’s negligence in the death of her child. All of these forces will eventually drive Pam to be the psychopath we meet in Friday the 13th, but we largely know what awaits her at the end of her story.
This journey to get there is the delightfully gory and disturbing path we will embark on over the next seven episodes. Check back to TV Obsessive soon for my recaps on Episodes 2-6 and Episodes 7-8.

Excellent recap! I look forward to the rest of the reviews.
Thank you, Anthony! Next two pieces will be out soon!