in

Dark Matter S2E8 Recap and Analysis: A Zigzag Line of a Hundred Tacks

“The Basic Oneness of Everything”

Dark Matter S2E8 - Zoom in on Jason and Amanda's hands, holding each other
Courtesy of Apple TV

The following recap contains spoilers for Dark Matter S2E8, “The Basic Oneness of Everything” (created by Blake Crouch, written by Jacquelyn Ben-Zekry & Blake Crouch, and directed by Guillermo Navarro).


Welcome, dear reader, as we continue to review the second season of the Apple TV series Dark Matter with Season 2 Episode 8: “The Basic Oneness of Everything.” I’ve been excitedly telling my friends, “Episode 8 is another Episode 5!” Except, that’s not quite right. This one was a true bottle episode. Not only is all the action on the same world (like in S2E5 and S2E6), it’s even limited to a single room. Like a one-act play where the set never needs to be changed out.

Last week I had all kinds of crazy theories dancing around in my head about who “the Librarian” could be and what this place might represent. This episode humanized the whole thing. The space still feels a little uncanny, perhaps, but after following a zigzag line of a hundred tacks, so to speak, we arrive at a place of healing and accepting. There is a lesson to be learned from this episode. A lesson that the entire series has been trying to teach. This one is not disconnected from the main action.

Dark Matter S2E8 - Amanda, blurry in the background, lies sleeping on a couch, Jason, foreground and in focus, sits on the floor leaning against the couch, awake
Doing the right thing

An Incredibly Unpleasant Evening

We start with the title card “two years ago.” Ah, back to starting out with a flashback sequence. This is familiar territory. The corridor morphs into the box as Jason opens the door and plunges in. He runs back out to retrieve a screaming Amanda, with a broken tree branch protruding out of her chest. There is a lot of screaming.

Jason shoots them both up and the corridor is back. Like Charlie in last episode, he puts it to the box that he needs help. He opens the door onto a catastrophe of plaster and dust everywhere. Now we get it. This is when the box appeared in the library. We’re watching Laurel’s original story. Cool.

Sure enough, Laurel arrives, shotgun in hand, thinking someone drove into her house. She takes charge of the situation and gets Amanda stabilized. There’s a lot more screaming, but Laurel has some impressive medical skills and a surprising amount of medical equipment as well. They drain the blood out of her lung, and Jason gets his scalp stapled back together.

Dark Matter S2E8 - Amanda and Jason stand before a massive sheet of plastic hanging behind them, both looking like they screwed up
They screwed up

Trauma

The next day, we get the scoop on Laurel from her conversation with Jason. In this world, they had 5/20 instead of 9/11, a dirty bomb attack on Chicago almost 20 years ago. They needed some place to care for the not critically wounded from the neighborhood. She had this huge house, and the skill set, and one thing led to another.

However, just like what is happening over in polite sex world, after 5/20 things got really authoritarian, really quick. She and her newfound friends did what they were supposed to do. Protest, march, speak out. The other side did what they always do. Made protesting illegal and had neighbors reporting on neighbors.

In a later conversation with Amanda, Laurel tells her the rest of the story. She shows her a picture of Rory, her best friend and the love of her life. One of the group that ran their makeshift hospital. He stayed quiet for her, but nonetheless someone turned him in for possession of banned materials. He died in a holding cell, waiting to hear the charges.

Here is another theme of the show playing out: how people deal with their trauma. The Jasons with their box psychosis. Daniela with her childhood abuse. Blair with her guilt over having killed an entire world. Laurel’s trauma changed the trajectory of her life. It taught her to cut herself off from the world and let no one in. Even if things are better now, they could change again in an instant. For all she knows, half of these books have been banned by now. What’s fine today could get you killed tomorrow.

Dark Matter S2E8 - Laurel stands with a scared look on her face, Leighton out of focus sitting in a chair behind her
Laurel recognizes that name

The Perfect Proprietor

Finally, Jason and Amanda set off together back into the box. Laurel keeps a vigil, setting up the doorbell chime to wake her if anyone comes through. One night, it finally ding-dongs, but it’s not Jason and Amanda returned. It’s some sort of steampunk version of Leighton. Actually, this is the Leighton Vance from Jason 1’s world, who paid Jason 2 a million dollars for every ampule he sent him off with to go adventuring back in S1E5.

Laurel invites her new guest in, settles him into a chair, and offers him a drink. She introduces herself and he replies that he’s Leighton—and now she’s offering him a shotgun. She won’t let him hunt Jason and Amanda down. He shocks her with the news that he’s a different Leighton. Right name, wrong version. A twist that her Jason and Amanda weren’t aware of yet.

He stays for a week. We find out that yes indeed, Laurel was a sailor, because she certainly swears like one. And probably cheats at cards. Leighton suggests maybe he comes back from time to time. Like a way station kind of thing. She is wise, knowledgeable, and has medical training and the space to help people. He knows she wants to help people, no matter how much she tries to pretend otherwise. So does the box, I would argue.

Dark Matter S2E8 - Blair stands on a ladder in front of the box, measuring the width of the door opening
Hands-on therapy

Healing

Leighton departs and Blair enters. The traumatized Blair of the murder hornet world. Laurel reaches out to take her hand and draw her across the threshold. Which is a small improvement for Blair, who shied away from human contact when Jason and Amanda last left her in S1E5.

She has no idea how to talk to people anymore, but Laurel doesn’t push her. Blair thought she was ready to go out into the box again, but once again bad things happened. She’s safe now, Laurel assures her, and she starts out small, with a simple walk around the neighborhood.

Blair’s real therapy is fixing up the wall where the box intruded. She puts her engineering know how into putting a whole new face on it, perfectly matched to the rest of the library. She even wires up a better doorbell sensor. It’s really beautiful.

Blair thinks Laurel saved her life. We can imagine that after this time of peace and healing, Blair went straight to World X as her next stop. We also see that each departure is hard on Laurel. She, too, is healing. She has once again opened up her home and her life, and she’s growing to care for these strangers.

Dark Matter S2E8 - Laurel sits in a chair in the library, looking over and raising her eyebrows knowlingly
Laurel has plans for the night

Another Chapter

Jason and Amanda return for a day off to reset. Every world they went to was close, but not his world. They have eight ampules left and Jason is starting to lose hope. The chances are getting smaller every day.

Talking to Laurel in private, Jason reveals that he is still holding onto the ideal of Daniela as his true match, a rare find given that most people just compromise. Laurel reminds him of their late-night chats where he described giving up quite a lot. There is no perfect match. There are just people who are worth making sacrifices for and your willingness to do so.

She’s come to realize that you have to hold tight to happiness where you find it. Because everything ends, and after it’s ending almost kills you, you’ll realize one day that it has become just another chapter in your story. Wise words, that ring a bit of the wisdom of Jason’s mother from S2E5.

When Amanda returns, Laurel briefs them that she’s had eight visitors while they were gone. Blair, Alex, Ryan, another Jason and Amanda, two solo Jasons, and a Leighton. All of this blows their minds. She’s got a night in planned for them. She is going to order Indian food, crank some music, she’s got a new card game that she’s dying to try, and, if they like, mushrooms. Leighton, dear Leighton, told her that shifting perspectives can help.

Dark Matter S2E8 - Laurel stands, reading from a book open in her hands, Amanda and Jason sit on the floor looking up at her
Laurel imparts some wisdom

Shifting Perspectives

While everyone is vibing on the shrooms, Laurel pulls a book and drops some more wisdom on them. “The voyage of the best ship is a zigzag line of a hundred tacks.” The way she sees it, life takes you here and there, and it can feel all random and tragic and insane. Then one day, it’s like, ooh, wow, I was always coming here. If you made the choices that brought you here genuinely, you’ll be at peace with where you end up.

On departure day, Amanda walks in very obviously unprepared to go traveling. She sits Jason down and gives him the same speech she gave him in S1E7. She’s found out that the Amanda of this world stayed in Brazil and so here once again, she is presented with a perfect world for her to stay in. As before, she says her presence has become a distraction for him. He has a world and a family that he is looking for. She doesn’t have that. She’s completely alone except for Laurel and him, and he’s not even her Jason.

Dark Matter S2E8 - Jason and Amanda look lovingly into each other's eyes
Living in the moment

People Worth Making Sacrifices For

That said, she doesn’t spend Christmas alone. She, of course, spends it with Laurel, and a surprise guest, Leighton. He offers to take her traveling with him but no, she’s going to sort out her life here. Pat says they could use a psychologist at the hospital and Laurel knows a guy who can get her some fake papers. Of course she does.

Jason likely did spend Christmas alone, which gave him some time to think. Having burned up six of the last eight ampules, he continues to be unsuccessful in trying to find his world. None of the ones he explored on his own were even remotely close to his. Amanda was wrong. It’s not because of her that he could not find his world. It’s because of him.

After some time passes, Jason gives Amanda a gift. A Polaris star pendant. No coincidence that this is the same symbol Charlie chose for the family to get as tattoos back on World X. There, the family was the guiding star for Jason. In this world, he has finally realized that Amanda has been his guiding star all along. This is where he was always meant to be.

Dark Matter S2E8 - Jason and Charlie sits beside each other on a couch in the library, both smiling
A reunion of sorts

Fatherly Advice

One year later, we catch back up to Charlie’s arrival. Now we know, Jason (I suppose we should start referring to him as Jason 32 now) was the mystery guest that Laurel brought in to help Charlie. After a little bit of catch up, we finally get to the real issue. Max is Charlie’s trauma. For 14 years, he sometimes feels like Max is there and he’ll go to tell him something. It’s crazy, but he just wants to know what it’s like to have him say something back.

Jason actually thinks that’s the best use of the box ever. Charlie is an adult now and he has to own his choices, be responsible. So, he should go see Max if he can, but Jason wants him to promise that he’ll say goodbye and stop looking back. The danger of the box is in how it tempts you with infinite regret. If he chooses the real, genuine life that he wants, he won’t need to look back.

Dark Matter S2E8 - Leighton stands in front of the box in the dark, mirrored shades on and wearing a cool jacket with the collar turned up
Steampunk Leighton

Quick Takes

A couple of quick takes on the rest of the episode:

  • I knew something was up when they began right away with the opening credits, no opening scene. They’ve only done that once before, and you can guess which episode that was.
  • My favorite tertiary character is always going to be slacker Ryan, but man, steampunk Leighton is running neck and neck with him. Watching Laurel and Leighton playing cards was a lot like watching the two Ryans weave their tale at the bar. I was smirking from ear to ear.
  • What if Daniela comes through to the way station next, looking for Charlie? Wouldn’t that be something.
  • One of the names Laurel mentions as having visited her is Alex. This would be one of the two volunteer pilots who went in after Blair failed to return.
  • The book that Laurel reads from is Self-Reliance by Ralph Waldo Emerson. The literary references are something else this episode has in common with Episode 5. Laurel knew right where to go for that quote. I’m guessing that’s something she’s read to herself more than a few times.
  • Another similarity to Episode 5 was the music. Once again, we get mostly score, enhancing all the scene work wonderfully. There are no montages set to hand-picked gems.
  • The one exception being the record playing in the background while Amanda and Jason are lying on the floor talking. The song there is “Memória” by Rosalía featuring Carminho. Naturally, a song about lost love and memory. It is utterly perfect. They also replay it for the ending credits.
  • A few tidbits from the official podcast for S2E7. One is that the writers refer to the pyramid as the “Super Ultra Mega Box.” Love that. They connect some dots by revealing that, in their minds, for Jason 1 to truly understand the box well enough to shut it down, he had to become Jason 2. Which is what happened when he shoved MacNamara in the box (just like Jason 2 did to Jason 1, except much more dastardly). Amanda Brugel (Blair) is their guest and she provides some insight into Blair’s motivations and how they transformed from Season 1 to Season 2. They also said that there are a lot of Easter eggs built into the library set.
Dark Matter S2E8 - A framed photo of seven people standing on a staircase looking down, held in hands
Laurel’s friends

Best lines of the episode:

  • “Oh, oh, oh, we will not be inviting those mother f***ers into my house.”
  • “You believe me.” “Well, it’s all too wild and dumb to be faked.”
  • “Hey. You’re doing the right thing.”
  • “So, no strangers in my house.” “We’re strangers.” “Do I seem happy about it?”
  • “Look at this. I’m going to be able to wash my hair.” “Thank God.”
  • “You are not disposable.” “You’re not him.”
  • “I didn’t know I was a coward until then.”
  • “You traveled. Bad things happened. You stopped. You traveled again. More bad things.”
  • “You’re a bad a** b****.” “Well, back atcha.”
  • “There is no perfect match. There’re just people who are worth making sacrifices for and your willingness to do so.”
  • “I adore you.”
  • “I wanted him to love me. He never did.” “Cuz he’s an idiot.”
  • “I just want to know what it’s like to have him say something back.”
Dark Matter S2E8 - Jason stands outside the box looking at Charlie, his back to us, standing inside it
Saying goodbye

Conclusion

Episode 5 and Episode 8 are two bookends to the same life lesson. Episode 5 focused on letting go of the past. That was a different life. Episode 8 focuses on letting go of the future. We tack our ship back and forth, trying to navigate the day-to-day, until one day we look up and realize we are at our destination. A place completely unplanned and frankly unplannable. Where we are is where we were headed all along. If the choices that led you here were made genuinely, you’ll have no regrets.

That’s all for this week. Please let us know your thoughts and feelings about this week’s episode, and any theories you have on what’s to come, in the comments below. Remember that TV Obsessive will provide continuing coverage of Dark Matter throughout Season 2 and beyond.


All images courtesy of Apple TV

Written by Brien Allen

Brien Allen is the last of the original crazy people who responded to this nutjob on Facebook wanting to start an online blog prior to Twin Peaks S3. Some of his other favorite shows have been Vr.5, Buffy, Lost, Stargate: Universe, The OA, and Counterpart. He's an OG BBSer, Trekkie, Blue Blaze Irregular, and former semi-professional improviser. He is also a staunch defender of putting two spaces after a period, but has been told to shut up and color.

8 Comments

Leave a Reply
  1. Love your recap/review and thank you for identifying the wonderful music played in the scene where Jason and Amanda are talking and also over the end credits. I am going to find the full version of Memoria!

    S2 Ep8 may be my favorite episode of the series thus far. Also loved S2 Ep5. Refocused on the human cost of decisions made without full consideration of the context. A lesson our current world needs to learn. Fast.

    Look forward to your reviews of the two remaining episodes! And as an aside… I also demand a double space after periods; graphically and visually, it’s easier on the eye for Pete’s sake. And I will die on the hill of the Oxford comma; the whole controversy is pure laziness. Last one: And another Counterpart fan, yay!! Miss that show.

  2. Ep 8 doesn’t rise to the level of being an important part of the whole story. It’s the opposite. It’s a dud. Why do this to your avid watchers?
    Why should be care about Jason 24? We don’t. Or Amanda? We don’t. She’s already settled in “kind” Chicago and then racing for her life. It’s a lot of stories to wade through hoping we’ll see Charlie, given that was the cliff hanger and we all want to know!
    I don’t like when shows force people to wait for no good reason. Episode 8 was nothing but a punishing process—ending in sheer frustration. Treat your viewers with respect, man!

    • To each their own, but I really disagree. I think it’s a real strength of this series that it treats each version of each of these characters as a person with value and so on. There is no reason, in principle, we should care more about Jason 1 than any other Jason. We’ve just been following his story, and it probably will connect more directly with the plot in terms of what happens with the box, but do will Jason 2’s, and he’s the “bad guy”… Anyway, just to speak for myself I often tire of multiverse narratives because I stop caring about all of the versions of the characters (thinking back to something like the Arrowverse shows), and it’s striking to me how Dark Matter pulls off the opposite, and has since nearly the beginning (thinking about the death of Daniela in World 2, for example). So I found this episode to be really important to the story in terms of its meaning, if not it’s plot. I thought Brien did a good job laying out the themes the show is dealing with here. I assume we’ll get more action and plot movement in the next two episodes, but I love how contemplative this one is, and how it deepens our sense of each version of each person being distinct, with their own intrinsic worth and so on. “You’re not disposable.”

    • I COMPLETELY agree with this. I feel like at this point they are just dragging and dragging and dragging this on to create more episodes. I saw another comment that said Jason 1 is no more important than any other Jason. And that’s not valid. Jason 1 IS the story because he was the one we were introduced to and he’s the one that had his life stolen for no reason at all and we are essentially waiting for this never ending story to end yet they keep adding things to keep it going. Jason 1 is the entire reason the show exists. As viewers our loyalty should be to Jason 1 and his family. They are totally innocent. I’m honestly growing weary of watching this because it’s getting to the point that it’s just obnoxious and stupid.

      • Loyalty? it’s a TV show! And all these other Jasons (besides 2, of course) are also Jason 1s! Learn some perspective, that is what the show is trying to demonstrate.

  3. Delightful re-cap! You really immerse yourself into the episodes. This one really pulled on my heart strings. Thanks again, you really do a great job!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *